In the last month I have visited two grounds to watch live football. Chelsea’s Stamford Bridge and York City’s Bootham Crescent.
They were very different experiences that were both enjoyable for their own reasons. Chelsea was a footballing feast. The slick passing and penetrating pace of the game was world-class. The last time I had seen football that good was at the same ground over a year before.
York City however, brought something to the football experience Chelsea arguably will never be able to again.
Atmosphere.
York City’s Bootham Crescent is far from a cauldron of noise. The average attendance is around the 3,000 mark and much of the noise comes in the form of groans and idle chat about what the team are doing wrong.
But what the smaller club has never lost is the sense of community. You recognise those around you from the local chippy and if you go to an away game the same faces pop up outside the turnstiles. They are the city folk devoutly giving their time and money to their football club no matter what will occur on the pitch that day.
There has been a debate about the price of football rumbling on for a long time now, which is starting to come to a head as Liverpool fans staged a walk out mid-match the other week, whilst Manchester United fans have also been protesting to name but two.
Football at the end of the day, has become a business. Prices are changing and consequently the clientele able to attend along with it. But more alarmingly for the purists amongst us, the grounds are changing.
The prices continue to escalate and it’s not right, it is billionaires bleeding the working class dry. But somehow, so many shift their finances and continue to honour their season tickets, as is the importance of their football clubs in their lives.
But for me, where the trouble really starts, is stadium alteration. Club after club has either moved ground or have planning permission in place for expansion. Even if the faithful ever-presents have painstakingly raised their funds to still attend, in a larger ground you begin to dilute them.
More corporate seats are created, specially cushioned for the tailor-made suit of the casual businessman, invited as a courtesy to observe the match rather than be involved in it. That, of course, is only if those seats are filled. It seems unlikely that on any occasion the club or chairman will feel the need to invite a few thousand at their pleasure, so the majority of seats created sit there staring emptily at those across the way in the stand opposite.
Take The Emirates Stadium, home to Arsenal, and The Etihad Stadium, home to Manchester City. Both used to play at compact old-fashioned stadiums with bags of atmosphere. Arsenal’s Highbury housed 38,419 as opposed to their new home’s 60,432 capacity. But ask any true Arsenal fan where they were happier? Highbury.
Manchester City’s Maine Road was an institution in English football before it was torn down in favour of the soulless Etihad, that half empties with 80 minutes on the clock so that people can avoid the traffic.
At York City you pay £18 to stand behind the goal at the David Longhurst End. Granted, for the football you get that is still an inflated price. But you are not paying for just the football, you are paying for that warmth many will remember from the 80s and 90s. The unwavering camaraderie and catch up with a stranger you see once a fortnight over a half-time cup of tea at a greasy spoon cafe price.
Chelsea have plans to expand their stadium, but the atmosphere left South West London a long time ago. Tickets are sold as a tourist attraction, a chance to don some blue for the night and take some photos to scan through on the flight back home.
The days of Highbury and Maine Road have been and gone. Soon West Ham’s Upton Park will follow, and even Liverpool’s iconic Anfield is set to change for the worse. Tottenham’s White Hart Lane is to be left, another great ground of the English tradition.
Alas, even York City are to move. The beautiful home of the Minstermen, placed intricately between rows of houses within a stone’s throw of the city centre is to be bulldozed for further housing to be built for incoming residents.
York will move to a new Community Stadium on the ring road. Not a soul will be able to walk to the game, and it shall be a multiplex with swimming pool to boot. With a capacity of 8,000 whether it can maintain the atmosphere I speak so fondly of remains to be seen.
But for now at least, the modern fan is being forced to make a choice. Pay the big bucks for the big boys, or like an older footballer, prepare to prioritise what matters and drop down the divisions for that Saturday afternoon you grew up loving so much.





